They might look similar from the outside but there’s a few critical differences in how each of these smokers performs. You can also check out our article on the best vertical smokers for a comparison of the Weber Smokey Mountain to similar smokers. The only downside to this is that there’s no lip for the lid to sit securely on the base piece. But, you do need to be really careful not to knock the hot lid off.
He cut it in half, added three legs, a handle, and, well, the rest is history. Cue the sound of perfectly-grilled steaks and veggies sizzling away in celebration. Want to learn more about how motion control engineering can improve smoker and grill hinges?
If any warranty issue comes up, we’ll cover the cost of packing & shipping to the manufacturer from any Sportsman’s Warehouse location. It can cook at lower temperatures, without being drastically affected by snow, rains or cold weather. Even if you keep weber genesis 2 your EGG out in the backyard in a brutal climate, it won’t depreciate whatsoever. Same is not the case with the WSM, as it does not have an airtight lid. Big Green Egg is renowned to make all-in-one units that grill, smoke, sear, bake and even roast.
However, this smoker is built for performance, easy enough for a beginner to master, and much-praised by people who are experienced smokers. It’s expected that the interior of the smoker weber q will develop a patina from the accumulated smoke and the grates will discolor, just like any grill. However, the accumulated smoke can get thick enough to flake off the interior.
If you want the highest level of temperature control and price isn’t a big deal for you, then you might go with the BGE. But looking solely at the pros of a smoker, the WSM is the way to go. At about $100 more than the mid-size one, it is still sold at an obtainable price. If you decide to buy this and use it only to cook for a small family, you’ll likely lose in terms of fuel consumption.
Although they look like offset smokers, you have a side-mounted hopper that can be filled with cylindrical wood pellets , which is much better than a fire box. The pellets are delivered to the fire pot from the hopper, and the resulting smoke and heat from the combustion of the pellet will smoke your meat. Overall, compared to the BGE, the WSM will end up being more economical to you in terms of fuel and price.
For smoking pork shoulder or other long time smokes I will fill the Weber Smokey Mountain BBQ Smoker charcoal chamber almost full with unlit coals . Our R&D department develops high-quality, fairly priced grilling equipment. A larger, heavier grill is a great addition as the focal point of your backyard. However, a portable charcoal grill provides a must-have solution for all of your on-the-go grilling adventures such as tailgating and picnicking.