Bread Toasters & Pop Up Toasters

For some of our finalists, 1-inch-thick bread came out a bit uneven in terms of shading and quality. Several toasters, including the Hamilton Beach and the Oster could not accommodate the 1½-inch cut pieces; their slots were simply too narrow. The others performed with varying degrees of success, with the clear winner in this category being the Breville. The toasters that created the most consistent results adjusted the time that the toast spent in the slots while also altering the intensity of the heat. The toaster with the smallest variance in time between rounds, the Oster -TSSTTRJBG1, also produced some of the most similarly toasted slices round after round. Other toasters that offered close to uniform consistency were the Cuisinart and the Hamilton Beach.

For the KRUPS, the cut side is inserted facing the heating element, just like the other toasters we tested except for the Cuisinart – CPT620. Bagel connoisseurs demand a crunchy cut side and slightly chewy crust. We’re not bagel experts, but the KRUPS’ bagel met those requirements, though the crust was a little crunchy too.

4-slice capacity with individual toasting functions and shade dials work well for families. Push-button Toast, Defrost, Reheat, and Bagel controls are easy to use. Slots are wide and long enough to hold hand-cut bread and bagels. Offers Toast, Bagel, Reheat, Defrost, and Cancel functions, as well as 5 shade settings. Automatically toasts, defrosts, and reheats at the touch of a button. 2 control panels conveniently allow for different levels of toasting at the same time.

On the whole, there are a few more issues holding the Krups back. Then, even when it’s fully raised, smaller slices of bread and our breakfast pastry did not clear the edges of the slot, making pulling them out tricky, with lots of care needed. The top half of the slots seemed to be less hot than the bottom half, as evidenced by cuisinart griddler elite our bagel, which popped up two-toned. The Hamilton Beach defrosted the frozen pastry, and the filling was hot, but again, the right-facing side browned more. After we finished the testing, it came time to clean the crumb tray. We found that it’s easy to remove but doesn’t cover a large amount of surface area under the toaster.

After pressing down the lever and waiting for some time, the toast pops out. Toast, bake, broil, and warm with this compact designed toaster oven from Oster. The oven temperature controls and a 15-minute timer help alert you when your food is done. This oven includes a convenient baking pan and will make toast … We observed LED screens, timers, lever lifts that raise the toast higher out of the slots and push buttons that automatically lower and raise the food. We compared dings, beeps and the feeling you get from using and simply looking at the toaster in the kitchen to help determine the best of the best.

The KRUPS – KH320D50 is a moderately priced two-slice toaster that gave the most consistent results than the three other toasters that we tested for this update. To see how each toaster handled breads of different shapes and sizes, we toasted dozens of loaves of basic white bread, bagels, frozen waffles, and English muffins. For our white-bread test, we toasted three back-to-back rounds of Wonder bread slices to see how consistent the toast was from model cuisinart pots and pans set to model and batch to batch. These multiple batches showed us how well each toaster could regulate its temperature after heating up. (Remember, air frying is essentially just convection cooking!) Neither my big oven nor my toaster oven had a convection setting though, thus, I deemed this was a worthy purchase for me. Another big pro to this vs. using the convection setting on your oven is that it doesn’t need to preheat and cooks food much faster.

The bagel setting works by increasing the heat on just one side of the slot. Clearly, this technology has been well-developed, as we were pleased with most all of the bagels that popped up. The one disappointment was the Oster, which seemed to do the exact same thing to both sides of the bagel. The medium bagel setting was also much darker than we would have expected. Many of the toasters provide an evenly shaded slice from left to right on the same side, but there is a discernible difference between the top and bottom, with the bottom almost always being a bit darker. There was also often a large variation from one side of the bread to the other.

The self-centering feature means that the toaster can place the bread automatically for the best browning. The toaster is also dishwasher-friendly, so you can clean out all the cuisinart pots and pans set specks of dust and crumbs quickly and easily. The slots measure up to 1.5 inches wide and can accommodate thicker cuts of bread; you do not have to trim your toast separately.

cuisinart toaster

Check out these top toaster oven Black Friday 2021 deals to get you started on shopping. Consider the size of the pop-up toaster, once you’ve reviewed the construction material. Couples may be fine with a 2-slice toaster, but families with three or more members will benefit from a 4-slice toaster.